The discussion framework depends on the group. You might first invite participants to provide immediate feedback on what they have viewed. Questions to prompt this discussion include:
- What did you think of the film?
- What stood out for you?
- What did you learn about Deaf culture, community, and history?
- Did the film reinforce something you already knew about the Deaf community? Explain.
- Describe something of your experience that the film reflects.
- Describe anything in the film that you feel might have been left unsaid.
You can continue the discussion with some or all of the in-depth questions that follow. (Or, depending on the group, begin the dialogue with these.) These questions reference direct quotes from the film.
1A) Through Deaf Eyes begins with the following true or false quiz:
All deaf people use sign language.
Sign language is universal.
Deaf people live in a silent world.
Having a deaf child is a tragedy.
All deaf people would like to be cured.
[Answers: All are FALSE!]
- What does this “quiz” reflect? What does it imply?
- Do these questions represent common perceptions of the deaf? Explain.
- Does the film demystify issues related to deafness? Explain.
- What impact did the film make on your understanding of deafness?
1B) In the film, interviewees talk about being deaf and others’ perceptions of deafness. While you watch the videos below - keeping these questions in mind:
- What do these individuals’ statements suggest about common perceptions of deaf people?
- What do these comments suggest about how deaf people view themselves in the world?
- How do these comments strike you?
- Do you agree or disagree with their perceptions/opinions? Explain.
Marlee Matlin says:
“I’m a proud person who happens to be deaf. I don’t want to change it. I don’t want to wake up and suddenly say, ‘Oh my God, I can hear.’ That’s not my dream. It’s not my dream. I’ve been raised deaf. I’m used to the way I am. I don’t want to change it. Why would I ever want to change? Because I’m used to this, I’m happy.”
I. King Jordan says:
“When you talk to people who can hear and you ask them what do you think it would be like to be a deaf person, then all of their thinking is well, I couldn’t do this. Can’t, can’t, can’t, can’t, can’t . . . they would start listing all the things they can’t do. And I don’t think like that. Deaf people don’t think like that. We think about what we can do . . .”
CJ Jones says:
“What’s wrong with being deaf? I’m deaf. I’m fine. I function fine. I drive. I have a family. I’ve made a baby. I make people laugh. I travel. What the hell is going on? Like I have to hear that has nothing to do with it. It’s all about knowledge; it’s about the heart. It’s about abilities, about doing something you want and getting what you want out of life…Knowledge is the most powerful vehicle to success, not hearing, not speaking . . .”
Summer Crider says:
. . .“In terms of a disability, I don’t view myself as having a disability . . . I function like any other hearing person can. My deafness does not deprive me of anything. I can do anything I want. Except maybe sing.”
David James says:
“Being deaf is, well, it’s part of me. It’s something I have to deal with, but it doesn’t keep me from being happy. It doesn’t make me either happy or say. It’s like being a man instead of a woman, or being tall instead of short.”
Dr. Carolyn McCaskill says:
“Maybe a person can’t see and is that normal? Maybe it is. And maybe a person walks with a bit of a limp. Perhaps that’s normal to one person and not another. What about left-handedness? Is that abnormal or normal?”
2) In the film, interviewee Mark Morales says:
“We have this planet, which we call earth; we spell it EARth, so it relates to the ear, to speaking and hearing. There’s this other planet called EYEth. And that relates to the eye and the visual. So there are two worlds and I grew up on EARth. Now, I am on this other planet, EYEth, a world where all these possibilities are open to me.”
- What do Mark’s thoughts suggest about people who are deaf?
- What does he intimate about Deaf culture?
- How do his thoughts represent or counter perceptions about the physical condition of deafness?
3) In the film, interviewee Dr. Douglas Baynton says:
“Many people were immigrating to this country from Eastern Europe and southern Europe, and this made a number of Americans very nervous. Ethnic groups set up their own schools here; they published newspapers in their native languages. The deaf community too had their own newspapers, their own schools, and their own churches; and used a separate language, and so people began to think of deaf people as an ethnic group — a group that should be assimilated into the general population.”
Interviewee Summer Crider describes her experiences in a mainstream school and then as a student in a school for the deaf:
"In those early years, I was placed in a deaf program within a public school, so it was a mainstream setting. And then when I started to recognize I was different from everyone else, I started to begin to think what makes me different from them and it was the box and this wire that was attached to my head. So, I quit wearing it; I just took it off. And about 10th grade, I decided I needed a better social life, so I started checking things out. And I came across the Florida School for the Deaf. And made the switch to that school, and went back to wearing the implant again. And I began wearing it all the time. So, it’s kind of unusual, just the opposite of what you think because my parents were very concerned that once I went to the school for the deaf, that I would stop wearing it entirely, that I wouldn’t speak any longer, that I wouldn’t wear the implant. But the opposite is what happened and it’s because I had confidence in myself. Everybody there was just like I was; everybody else had a problem with their hearing, so it was OK. It gave me the opportunity to wear my implant and to feel like I fit in and really take advantage of everything that it had to offer.”
Dr. John (Stan) Schuchman describes growing up in his deaf family:
“My parents were deaf. My parents had many deaf friends. They had an active schedule. We went to deaf clubs. We went to deaf people’s homes. It was a natural community for me as a kid growing up. It was like a kid who grew up in an immigrant family where many of the friends spoke a different language . . .”
Lasander Saunders says:
“I was born hearing and then later I became deaf. I started going to a hearing church to worship, but I was missing so much. When I found out about a deaf church, I thought I [would] try that, and I saw the choir signing music. And the drum. And I felt so inspired. The preacher was good. And I could get worship here with deaf people. It was a great change in my life."
(Narration) . . . "Deaf communities had theatrical societies, literary circles, masquerade balls, organized debates, sports teams, and travel groups. The deaf culture had that had taken root in the schools for deaf children cropped up all across the country in deaf clubs for adults. People came together to sign, to help each other, and, quite simply, to have a good time.”
- Based on the film and these excerpted quotes, how would you describe the Deaf community?
- Would you describe the Deaf community as an ethnic community? Explain.
- How was/is the Deaf community formed?
- What does the creation of the Deaf community suggest to those outside of the community about, for example, deaf people’s abilities, desires, or interests?
- What challenges and/or divisions exist within this community?
- How is this community different from and/or similar to the notion of community/a community, in general?
4) Describe and discuss the ways the deaf/Deaf community has taken action — politically, as activists/protestors, through legislation, formation of associations — to ensure that its needs are recognized and honored? How has this action influenced not only the deaf/Deaf community, but the way in which society treats and engages with it.
5) The film points to the many technological products that have made an impact on deaf people. Describe this technology and its influence, both negative and positive.
6) Based on the film and the following quotes from the film, what paradoxes existed/exist within the Deaf community/society with regard to socio-political issues/points of view? What socio-economic conditions exist among the Deaf community?
(Narration) “But deaf society was like American society. And that wasn’t always good. In 1925, after an African American couple tried to attend a NAD convention, the deaf organization explicitly banned Black people from joining. The ban was in place for forty years. In the south, deaf schools — like all schools — were segregated for decades.”
Dr. Carolyn McCaskill describes the cultural differences in deaf communication:
“At the Black deaf school, our Black deaf culture flourished. We had basketball games. We had our dances. We had Black teachers. Moving then to a White deaf school, we all used sign language. But the signs that were being used were very different. The White deaf students would finger spell and then add some signs. As a Black deaf person, they would look at my signing and say that doesn't look like what they did as White deaf students. And so I found myself humiliated. I thought I was inferior and that somehow, our signs were subordinate to the signs that they were using. And so I tried to put away my signs and instead, adopt the signs that were used by the White students.”